
Species behavior more than anything you did wrong. Tree of heaven, black locust, sweetgum, callery pear, mulberry, poplar, and elm sucker aggressively; oaks and nearly all conifers essentially do not. Cutting during the spring flush, when root reserves peak, provokes the strongest response. On a living tree, basal sprouting is usually a stress signal instead — root damage, trunk injury, drought, or a tree planted too deep.
A ring of vigorous shoots around the rim of a cut stump, or shoots pushing up through bare lawn several feet away, sometimes in a line that follows a root. The leaves match the tree that was removed. Cut them and they return thicker and more numerous than before. On a still-living tree, the same thing shows up as a thicket at the base of the trunk.