
At the time of the damage: cut root ends showing in a trench wall, a scraped or re-graded surface inside the root area, ruts, a compacted pad where equipment or materials sat, or fresh fill spread over the roots. Later, and this is what most people actually notice: leaves smaller than usual, fall color arriving weeks early, dead twigs at the top and outer edges of the crown, sprouts erupting along the trunk, and a canopy thin enough to see sky through. The damaged side of the crown usually goes first, matching the side that was dug. The tree lost part of its absorbing root system and, wherever soil was compacted, the pore space its roots depend on for oxygen. Tree roots are shallow and wide — most of them in roughly the top foot of soil and extending well past the dripline — so a trench that looked comfortably far from the trunk usually was not. Compaction does comparable damage and is invisible from the surface. And roots cut on one side means anchorage lost on that side, so this is a stability question as much as a health question.
Within days. Normally a hazardous tree removal job, $800–$5,000 around Indianapolis depending on size and access.
Frequently, and the decision turns on how much root area was lost and where. Roots cut on one side only, close to the trunk on that side, is the worst case for both survival and stability. What genuinely helps: deep irrigation through every dry spell for at least the next two or three growing seasons, wide thin mulch over the root zone, compaction relief with an air tool or vertical mulching rather than tilling, and nothing else that adds stress. What does not help, despite still being sold: crown reduction 'to balance the roots' — a damaged tree needs its leaves to rebuild roots — plus heavy nitrogen fertilizer and injections. Removal is right when roughly half or more of the root plate was destroyed, when the tree has begun to lean or the soil has cracked opposite the cutting, or when it stands over the new house. The most valuable thing an arborist can do is arrive before the excavator: protective fencing at a tree protection zone, commonly set with a rule of thumb of one foot of radius per inch of trunk diameter, costs almost nothing against what it saves.