
Northern Red Oak can work here, with caveats. Native and common statewide, one of Indiana's most valuable timber species, and it holds up in urban sites better than most oaks thanks to good salt and air-pollution tolerance. Most mature red oaks on central Indiana lots predate the subdivision — they are remnant woodland trees the builder left standing, which also means their root systems have already been through a construction site.
Acorns are the standing complaint — large, round, shallow-capped, dropped in quantity in a mast year every two to five years, hard on mower decks, slippery on drives and steps, and a squirrel magnet. Add long yellow-green catkins in May that clog gutters and stick to car paint, and a heavy late-season drop of tough, slow-rotting leaves.
Red oak drives a taproot on deep soil and then builds a handful of heavy structural laterals near the surface that spread well past the drip line — those are what a driveway or utility excavation severs, and cutting them on one side is a common cause of oak failure years later. Roots also graft naturally between neighboring oaks and transmit oak wilt underground, which is why a confirmed infection sometimes means trenching to sever grafts, not just removing one tree.