
Chinkapin Oak can work here, with caveats. Native and scattered through central Indiana, more frequent on limestone-influenced ground and river bluffs than out on the flat till plain. It is being planted increasingly as a street and yard replacement in the gap left by ash removals and the Callery pear ban, so young ones are appearing in yards where homeowners have no idea what species they own.
The acorns are genuinely sweet and low in tannin, so squirrels, deer and turkeys strip them fast — far less acorn nuisance than pin or red oak, which is a real selling point for homeowners. The actual complaint is a heavy, leathery leaf drop that mats down on turf and packs gutters, plus a short spring catkin drop that stains concrete drives.
It sends down a strong taproot as a seedling, which makes nursery stock hard to transplant but means established trees anchor well and rarely heave drives the way maples do. The roots chase calcium, so they exploit limestone gravel and old construction backfill rather than crowding foundation footings — it behaves better near structures than most large oaks.