
Removing a sugar maple around Indianapolis typically runs $400 to $1,900, with most jobs near $720. It is the tree everyone wants and the one that quietly dies in a subdivision — sugar maple is among the least salt- and compaction-tolerant shade trees there is, and it is no longer recommended for street planting anywhere in the Midwest. A sugar maple fifteen feet off a salted road on stripped subdivision clay is on a decline clock from the day it goes in, which is why so many central Indiana quotes on this species are removals of trees that are only forty years old.
Roughly 60-75 ft tall and 40-50 ft wide in the open, easily past 100 years in a woodlot and often 200+, though street-side in salted compacted soil many do not reach 60. At full size it is a large-tree removal — over a house or drive it means a crane or heavy rigging, near the top of the residential bracket, and the dense hard wood makes it slow to cut and process.
Better in ice than its reputation suggests — in the ISA's Urbana ice-storm survey sugar maple showed little severe damage, because its coarse, relatively low-density branching sheds ice load better than fine-twigged species. When a sugar maple does fail here it is almost always decay-driven or a split at an old codominant fork with included bark, not general brittleness, so the inspection is about unions and cavities rather than crown weight.